Skip to content

Search Volume versus Impressions
Understanding the gaps between SEO metrics

By Updated at 1 min read

You ranked for promising keywords in terms of search volume but the actual traffic is disappointing?

Let’s dive into the difference between search volume and impressions to understand the gap between theory and practice, whether your decision-making tool is Google Search Console, Google Analytics, Semrush, Ahrefs, Ranxplorer or Seobserver.

These 2 metrics each have a sibling: estimated SEO traffic and number of clicks, which allow you to evaluate the performance of one or more URLs.

In this article, we’ll trace each of these 4 metrics back to their data source and explain the discrepancies — and most importantly, which data to use and when.

SEO Impressions vs. Volume: reliability of SEO metrics

1. Average Monthly Search Volume

The average monthly search volume, simply called search volume, represents the average number of times a keyword is searched on Google each month.

It indicates the overall interest of users in a topic and its seasonality over a year.

This data, displayed in almost every SEO & GEO tool, comes from Google Ads and its Google Keyword Planner.

3 issues arise:

  • Google provides this data for a single keyword while it actually corresponds to a group of keywords. For the keyword “pizza,” Google Ads suggests pizzam and opizza with the same volume, even though these 2 variants are typos and certainly don’t have a search volume of 1.5K/month.
  • A gap exists between Google Ads data and SEO & GEO tool data depending on how they handle the first issue and when they imported the information.
  • Trending keywords struggle to reflect a number that matches the changing reality.

2. Impressions in Google Search Console

Impressions represent the number of times a page from your site appeared in Google search results, whether it was clicked or not. This metric is only available in Google Search Console and in tools that import your Search Console property data.

It measures your site’s actual visibility on Google and is more precise than the Volume indicator, provided you’re in the top 10 for a query with low personalization — particularly the addition of a local overlay on a generic query.

It allows you to prioritize important pages based on the SEO traffic KPI, and combined with metric #4, it highlights potential optimizations, particularly on CTR (click-through rate).

3. Estimated SEO Traffic

Estimated SEO traffic for a keyword or URL is a projection of the number of visits an organic position on Google’s results page could receive based on the search volume of the keywords it targets. Most calculation methods for this traffic are proprietary and therefore different. They are based on a CTR curve by Google position, whose value depends heavily on how position and aggregation are measured.

With an already relatively soft base indicator — volume — combined with increasingly heterogeneous SERPs, this metric should be taken as a trend rather than an absolute figure.

Some tools rely on pixel position in the results page rather than organic position, which significantly reduces variability related to result types.

Estimated SEO traffic based on pixel position for the first position is a prime indicator for evaluating whether it’s worth working on a keyword, compared to the overly generic volume indicator.

It allows you to estimate a site’s performance without direct access to Google Analytics or Search Console. It provides a comparative view between several competing sites.

4. Number of Clicks

Clicks correspond to the number of times a user clicks on a result and actually visits a site. They are an excellent performance indicator because they reflect a direct interaction with your content. This data comes from Google via Search Console, just like impressions.

Combined with impressions, it allows you to calculate CTR — the click-through rate on your result. A low CTR might indicate a title that’s not relevant to the main intent of the keyword: an optimization worth pursuing.

Why is there such a large gap between SEMrush traffic and actual clicks?

The gap between SEMrush’s estimated traffic and actual clicks comes from methodological differences: SEMrush relies on average positions and theoretical CTRs, while Search Console measures real clicks. Rich results (Google Ads, Featured Snippets, carousels) divert some traffic, and good positioning doesn’t guarantee a high click-through rate. Additionally, seasonal variations and competition influence visibility.

When to use impressions, clicks, or search volume as a KPI?

  • Search volume is useful upstream, for choosing keywords and estimating a topic’s potential before creating content.
  • Estimated SEO traffic is a good indicator for comparing yourself against competitors for whom you don’t have Search Console data.
  • Impressions and clicks (Search Console data) allow you to evaluate the actual visibility of a page in Google and prioritize optimizations to push to production based on real potential.

Search volume and estimated SEO traffic support the initial strategy and competitive analysis, while impressions and clicks are essential indicators for prioritizing optimizations in a second phase.

AI, SEO and Web strategy session

Which SEO metric should drive your next decision?

Put Search Console, estimated traffic, and business objectives in context before assigning budget to the next optimization.

Review my SEO priorities

€350 excl. VAT, up to 90 minutes

Email • RSS • Twitter

Get notified of new posts

Also read: